Skip to content
police chief search webpage

Digital Transparency: Cities Create Webpages for Open Police Chief Searches

The search for a new police chief today is not just a routine process but a dynamic and evolving one. Cities are increasingly leveraging online tools to engage their communities and ensure a transparent selection process. Among these tools, online community surveys have emerged as a particularly effective method for gathering input on the qualities and qualifications desired in a new police chief. These surveys, along with community forums where citizens can interact with the final candidates, reflect a broader trend towards inclusivity and transparency in public service appointments. Role of Police Chief The role of the police chief is one of the most visible and critical positions in any local government. The individual in this position sets the standards for law enforcement practices and community relations. But it's not just about the police chief, it's about the community. The citizens are the ones who live with the decisions made by the police chief, and they are increasingly demanding to have a say in who is chosen. Ensuring that the community’s voice is heard and considered can build trust and improve the relationship between the police force and the community it serves. So, how can cities effectively gather and incorporate…

Read more
should be police chiefs be elected?

Untangling the Knot: Can Electing Police Chiefs Depoliticize Policing?

Unlike sheriffs, the majority of police chiefs in the United States are appointed by City or County Managers, Mayors, Commission Chairs, or some other official. Typically, in small and large cities, the police chief reports directly to the mayor or other elected official, which can make the police chief's job difficult because of politics. In the cities in between, a professional, such as a City Manager, appoints the police chief.This gives the chief some distance from politics, at least in theory. Problem In the intricate web of law enforcement, the intersection of politics and policing is undeniable. From setting priorities to allocating resources, political considerations often permeate every facet of police work. Against this backdrop, the question arises: Can electing police chiefs take the politics out of policing? This inquiry delves into the complexities of law enforcement leadership, examining the potential merits and pitfalls of electoral processes in depoliticizing policing. Elected Police Chiefs? Up until a few years ago, I had no idea that police chiefs in some cities are elected instead of appointed by City or County Managers, Mayors, or Commission Chairs. Years ago, I ran across a news article about Chief Garrett Grogan of the Patterson, Louisiana Police…

Read more
internal or external candidates

State and Local Restrictions Create a Police Chief Hiring Challenge

For most police chief searches, the process is pretty straightforward. If so inclined, the city manager or Mayor just picks the police chief from an internal candidate pool. Usually, though, the job is advertised, and internal and external candidates apply. However, the hiring authority has no choice in some states and cities as the candidate pool is limited to internal candidates only. For example, the City of Akron's recent announcement that it will only consider internal candidates for the next chief of police highlights a significant challenge posed by a little-known state law. This law mandates that all vacancies above the entry-level in safety forces must be filled internally, a revelation that surfaced during legal consultations. Akron’s decision brings several challenges and considerations regarding local governance and police administration to light. Legal Restrictions and Local Governance The primary challenge stems from the legal straitjacket the city finds itself in due to state law. While the city charter usually allows some leeway, stating that promotions should occur internally "whenever practicable," it does not conflict significantly enough with state law to provide any room for maneuver. This legal backdrop restricts the city's ability to select its top officials based on a broader…

Read more
Back To Top