Red Flags for Police Chief Candidates: When to Walk Away from a Job Offer

The role of a police chief is one of immense responsibility, leadership, and influence. For experienced law enforcement professionals seeking to step into or advance within this critical role, finding the right job is more than just a career move—it’s a decision that can impact the community, the police department, and the individual’s professional and personal life.

Understanding the Importance of Job Fit

The concept of “fit” in a job is crucial for any profession, but it is especially significant for police chiefs. The right fit ensures that the candidate’s values, skills, and leadership style align with the department’s needs and the community’s expectations. A poor fit can lead to frustration, conflict, and, ultimately, failure to achieve the goals that both the department and the candidate have set.

1. Assessing the Community and Its Needs

One of the first considerations for police chief candidates is the community they will serve. Understanding the community’s demographics, crime rates, social issues, and overall expectations for law enforcement is critical. A police chief must not only be capable of handling the current challenges but also be in tune with the community’s culture and values.

A candidate might find that their background and expertise are better suited to a particular type of community—whether it’s urban, suburban, or rural. For example, a candidate with experience in a large metropolitan area might struggle to adjust to the dynamics of a small town where policing is more community-focused and less driven by high crime rates.

2. Evaluating the Department’s Culture

Every police department has its own culture, which can be shaped by historical practices, leadership styles, and the relationship between the police and the community. Before applying for a job, candidates should research the department’s reputation, internal dynamics, and how it has handled past challenges.

A department with a history of discord, low morale, or poor community relations may require a police chief with strong transformational leadership skills. Conversely, a well-functioning department may benefit more from a leader who can maintain stability and continue positive trends. Candidates should honestly assess whether they are equipped to handle the unique challenges the department presents.

3. Considering the Political Environment

The political landscape within a city or town can greatly influence the role of a police chief. In some areas, police chiefs are expected to work closely with local government officials and may face significant pressure to align with political agendas. In other cases, the position might be more independent, with a focus on law enforcement rather than politics.

Candidates should consider whether they are comfortable navigating the political intricacies of a particular job. This includes understanding the expectations of city councils, mayors, and other stakeholders. If a candidate feels that the political environment would compromise their integrity or ability to lead effectively, it might be wise to reconsider pursuing the role.

4. Skills and Expertise

The right fit also involves matching a candidate’s skills and expertise with the specific challenges and needs of the department. For instance, a police chief candidate with a background in handling gang violence and high-crime urban areas might excel in a department struggling with these issues.

However, this same candidate might find themselves out of their depth in a small town where the focus is on community policing and managing low-level, non-violent crimes. A poor fit in this regard can lead to ineffective leadership, where the strategies and policies implemented by the police chief do not address the core issues facing the community, leading to unmet goals and dissatisfaction from both the department and the public.

5. Leadership Style

Leadership style is another crucial component of fit. Different departments require different types of leadership depending on their current state and the challenges they face. A department undergoing a significant transformation may need a police chief with a strong, decisive leadership style to drive change and overcome resistance.

On the other hand, a department that is already stable and well-functioning might benefit more from a leader who adopts a collaborative and inclusive approach, fostering a sense of unity and shared purpose among officers and staff. When the leadership style of a police chief does not align with the department’s needs, it can result in friction, decreased morale, and an inability to effectively guide the department toward its goals.

Why Candidates Should Avoid Certain Jobs

While finding the right job is important, it’s equally crucial to recognize when a position is not a good fit. Here are some reasons why a police chief candidate should either avoid applying for a specific job or decline an offer:

Lack of Alignment with Personal and Professional Values

A police chief’s personal and professional values should align with the department’s mission and the community’s expectations. If a candidate feels that the department’s practices, policies, or the community’s expectations contradict their core values, accepting the job could lead to ethical dilemmas and dissatisfaction.

For instance, if a candidate values community-oriented policing but the department emphasizes aggressive tactics, the role might not be suitable. Misalignment can lead to frustration and a lack of fulfillment in the role.

Insufficient Support and Resources

A police chief needs adequate support from local government, department staff, and community stakeholders to be successful. If a candidate discovers that the department is severely underfunded, lacks necessary resources, or has significant staffing issues, they should carefully weigh the risks.

Taking on a role without sufficient resources can set a police chief up for failure, as they may struggle to implement necessary changes or maintain public safety. A lack of support from key stakeholders can also make it difficult to lead effectively and build trust within the department and the community.

Poor Governance and Oversight

In some municipalities, police chiefs may encounter situations where there is inadequate governance or oversight. This can manifest as a lack of clear policies, inconsistent support from local government, or interference from politicians in day-to-day operations. When governance is weak or overly political, it can make it difficult for a police chief to execute their duties effectively.

The lack of clear, consistent oversight can lead to confusion, poor decision-making, and a compromised ability to implement long-term strategies. If a candidate perceives that the local government does not have a strong commitment to supporting law enforcement in a balanced and fair manner, it may be a sign to avoid the job.

Unreasonable Expectations

Sometimes, a job may come with unrealistic expectations that are unlikely to be met regardless of the police chief’s abilities. For example, a community might expect immediate reductions in crime rates without understanding the complexities involved or the time needed to see real change.

If the expectations placed on the police chief are not reasonable or achievable, it could lead to undue stress and potential damage to the candidate’s professional reputation. It’s important for candidates to have a clear understanding of what is expected of them and whether those expectations are grounded in reality.

Negative Department Reputation

A department with a long-standing negative reputation may pose significant challenges for a new police chief. Whether the issues stem from corruption, misconduct, or poor community relations, it can be difficult to turn around a department with deep-rooted problems.

Candidates should consider whether they are prepared to take on the responsibility of reforming a troubled department. This kind of challenge can be rewarding, but it also comes with the risk of being associated with the department’s past failures if change does not come quickly or easily.

For example, in 1996, Chief Bobby Moody took on the role of police chief for the Marietta, GA Police Department, stepping into a department that was fraught with dysfunction and in desperate need of transformation. The challenges were significant, as the department was not only struggling with internal discord and low morale, but it also lacked the professionalism and modern policing practices necessary to effectively serve the community.

Chief Bobby Moody Experience

Chief Moody recognized that to bring about the necessary changes, he would need to overhaul not just the operational procedures, but the very culture of the department. This kind of deep-rooted transformation is never easy and often meets with considerable resistance.

Over the next five years, Chief Moody embarked on a comprehensive reform initiative aimed at professionalizing the department, implementing modern policing strategies, and restoring public trust. His approach included the introduction of rigorous training programs, the adoption of community-oriented policing practices, and the establishment of clear accountability mechanisms.

However, the road to reform was anything but smooth. Chief Moody found himself constantly under attack, both from within the department and from external forces. Internally, he faced pushback from officers resistant to change, some of whom were deeply entrenched in the old ways of operating. The transformation he was spearheading threatened the status quo, and as a result, he became the target of numerous grievances filed by those who opposed his reforms.

Externally, the media was often critical of his efforts, publishing hit pieces that questioned his leadership and the direction in which he was taking the department. These attacks were not just limited to critical articles; they were part of a broader narrative that sought to undermine his credibility and the legitimacy of his reforms. Despite this, Chief Moody remained steadfast in his mission, understanding that such resistance was an inevitable part of enacting meaningful change.

The experience of Chief Bobby Moody in Marietta serves as a powerful example of the challenges faced by police chiefs who take on the difficult task of transforming a dysfunctional department. His story underscores the importance of resilience, determination, and a clear vision in the face of adversity. While the process was arduous and fraught with obstacles, the eventual success of his reforms highlighted the critical role of strong, unwavering leadership in overcoming internal and external opposition to create a more effective, professional, and community-oriented police force.

Not every police chief candidate has the intestinal fortitude and skill to transform a department.

High Turnover Rate Among Previous Chiefs

If a department has a history of frequent turnover among its police chiefs, this can be a red flag. High turnover often indicates underlying issues such as toxic work environments, unrealistic job expectations, or ongoing conflicts with local government or the community.

A candidate should investigate why previous chiefs left and consider whether those same issues could affect their ability to succeed in the role. Taking on a position with a history of instability can set a candidate up for the same fate, leading to a short and possibly contentious tenure.

Hostile Work Environment

A hostile work environment, whether due to internal politics, harassment, discrimination, or a deeply divided workforce, is a significant reason to avoid a police chief position. In such an environment, even the most capable leader may find it impossible to foster collaboration, trust, or positive change.

If a candidate identifies a culture of hostility within the department—whether from previous reports, media coverage, or their own observations during the interview process—it may be wise to steer clear. Attempting to lead in such an environment without strong backing and the authority to make necessary changes can be an exercise in futility and damage the candidate’s career and well-being.

Legal and Financial Troubles

If a department or the city it serves is mired in legal issues, such as lawsuits related to police misconduct, or is facing financial instability, this could be a strong reason to avoid the job. Legal troubles can consume a significant amount of a police chief’s time and resources, distracting from other critical responsibilities and tarnishing the department’s reputation.

Financial instability can lead to budget cuts, layoffs, and an inability to adequately support the department’s operations. These challenges can severely limit a police chief’s effectiveness and make it difficult to achieve long-term goals. 

Unrealistic Timeframes for Change

Some job offers may come with the expectation that a new police chief will implement rapid changes, such as quick reductions in crime rates or immediate improvements in community relations. While ambition is important, unrealistic timeframes can set a candidate up for failure.

Meaningful change often takes time, particularly in environments with entrenched problems or where there is resistance to new approaches. If the expectations are not aligned with what is realistically achievable, accepting such a job could lead to disappointment, frustration, and an eventual exit under unfavorable circumstances.

Personal and Family Considerations

Finally, candidates should not overlook personal and family considerations. The role of a police chief often involves long hours, high stress, and significant public scrutiny. If the job would negatively impact a candidate’s personal life or require relocation to an undesirable area, it might not be worth the professional gain.

Family support is crucial for anyone taking on such a demanding role. Candidates should discuss potential job offers with their family members to ensure that everyone is on board with the decision and the changes it might bring to their lives.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

For police chief candidates, finding the right job is about more than just advancing their careers—it’s about ensuring that they can effectively lead, make a positive impact, and find satisfaction in their work. By carefully considering factors such as community needs, department culture, political environment, and personal values, candidates can identify roles that are the best fit for their skills and aspirations.

Equally important is recognizing when a job may not be the right fit. Avoiding positions with misaligned values, insufficient resources, or unreasonable expectations can help candidates steer clear of roles that could lead to professional and personal dissatisfaction.

In the end, making the right choice is about finding a balance between career ambition and the realities of the job. Police chiefs play a critical role in shaping the safety and well-being of the communities they serve, and finding the right fit is essential for both their success and the success of the department.

Sign up below for my Top Cop Newsletter.