Navigating the Challenges of Accepting a Police Chief Appointment When You Are Not the First Choice

Taking on the role of a police chief is an enormous responsibility, one that comes with its fair share of challenges and complexities. But what happens when you step into this role amid controversy, where you were not the first recommendation of the city manager, and the city council’s vote was not unanimous? In this article, we will delve into the unique difficulties and obstacles that arise when accepting such an appointment, and how police chiefs can effectively navigate them while striving to build trust, transparency, and a sense of unity within their departments and communities.

I have been a student of police chief searches for many years and have participated in several myself. In most instances, the City Manager or Mayor’s recommendation is accepted by the City Council, and the vote is usually unanimous. However, that is not always the case.

I recently ran across an article where the City Manager’s recommendation of a candidate for police chief was rejected by the City Council. The City Manager then brought forth his second recommendation, which was accepted by a majority of the City Council. Based on the way the article is worded, the selection of the internal candidate was not unanimous.

The City Manager’s first choice was an outside candidate, while his second choice for police chief was an inside candidate. Apparently, the majority of the City Council wanted a police chief from within the ranks of the Laredo Police Department, which was likely why the first candidate was rejected.

If you are appointed as a police chief, but you were not the first choice or your appointment was not unanimous, you have an important decision to make. Do you accept the appointment? After all, you will likely face many obstacles and challenges. One of the biggest challenges will be what happens if a few people on the City Council who voted for you change their minds about your employment. Your position could be at risk.

Buy, if you accept the position, and for the sake of argument, let’s assume you have. Now what? How do you manage the issue and set yourself up for success?

Below are a few observations and suggestions that might help.

1. The Initial Turmoil

When a candidate for the position of police chief is not the city manager’s first choice, it can create immediate tensions and skepticism. The city manager plays a crucial role in the selection process, and their preferred candidate typically carries a sense of legitimacy. When someone else is appointed, it can lead to speculation about political interference, personal bias, or a lack of faith in the chosen candidate’s abilities.

2. Gaining the Trust of the City Manager

One of the foremost challenges is gaining the trust and support of the city manager. When you were not their first choice, it’s essential to work diligently to demonstrate your competence, commitment, and dedication to the role. Open communication, a willingness to collaborate, and showcasing your qualifications can help build a stronger working relationship.

3. Unanimous Council Vote vs. Divided Opinion

A unanimous city council vote is typically seen as a vote of confidence in the new police chief. However, when the vote is not unanimous, it suggests that there are differing opinions and concerns within the council itself. It’s crucial to recognize that not all council members may fully support your appointment and to proactively address their concerns.

4. Managing Internal Dissent

When a police chief’s appointment is controversial, it often creates divisions within the police department. Some officers may have preferred the initial recommendation or harbor doubts about your suitability for the role. It’s essential to acknowledge these concerns and work toward unity within the department.

5. Building Trust within the Community

The community’s trust in the police force is paramount. An appointment shrouded in controversy can erode this trust. To overcome this challenge, a new police chief must engage in outreach efforts, meet with community leaders, and actively listen to the concerns of citizens. Transparency and a commitment to reform and community policing are key to rebuilding trust.

6. Handling Media Scrutiny

Controversial appointments often attract significant media attention. Police chiefs must be prepared to face tough questions, criticism, and public scrutiny. Developing effective media relations and communication strategies is crucial to managing the narrative and ensuring that the department’s side of the story is accurately represented.

7. Maintaining Good Morale Among Officers

The morale of police officers can be significantly affected by a controversial appointment. Officers who may have supported the initial recommendation may feel disheartened, while those who had reservations about your appointment may be skeptical about your leadership. Open and regular communication, as well as a focus on a shared mission and values, can help boost morale.

8. Proving Your Leadership

As a police chief appointed amid controversy, you will constantly be under the microscope. It’s essential to prove your leadership abilities through actions, not just words. Implementing meaningful reforms, enhancing training programs, and addressing any issues within the department head-on can demonstrate your commitment to improving the force.

9. Fostering Transparency and Accountability

Transparency and accountability are crucial components of effective law enforcement. When your appointment is contested, there may be increased scrutiny of your commitment to these principles. Developing clear policies and procedures, ensuring accountability for misconduct, and establishing community oversight mechanisms can help address these concerns.

10. Bridging Divides

One of the most significant challenges is bridging the divides that exist within the city, the council, and the police force itself. This requires a commitment to collaboration, active listening, and a willingness to work with all stakeholders to build a more inclusive and equitable community.

Conclusion

Accepting an appointment as police chief when you were not the first recommendation of the city manager and the city council’s vote was not unanimous is undoubtedly a challenging endeavor. However, it is also an opportunity to demonstrate resilience, leadership, and a commitment to the community you serve. By actively addressing concerns, fostering transparency, and building trust within both the department and the community, police chiefs can overcome the initial controversies and work towards creating safer and more cohesive cities for all residents.

Click below to sign up for periodic newsletter posts.