First Impressions Matter: 8 Techniques for Excelling in Your Police Chief Interview

In law enforcement, becoming a police chief is the pinnacle of one’s career. However, the path to securing this position is a challenging one. One of the most difficult aspects of becoming a police chief is standing out in the interview process, as there are usually many qualified candidates. A successful interview requires making a great first impression on the interviewers. This article will explore eight ways to make a great first impression during the interview.

1. Dress for Success

When it comes to interviews, dressing for success is a must. As a police chief, you will be the face of the department, and you need to present yourself professionally. The key is to wear comfortable clothing that makes you feel confident. A well-tailored suit and dress shoes for male candidates and a smart business outfit for female candidates is always a safe bet. If you are an internal candidate, showing up in uniform is a conservative move but not always the best choice, especially if there are multiple internal candidates.

2. Do Your Research

Before your interview, research the department and the community it serves. Knowing the department’s mission, values, and goals will help you tailor your responses to their priorities. Additionally, understanding the community’s demographics, crime rate, and current policing issues will help you demonstrate your knowledge and readiness to lead the department. Of course, if you are an inside candidate for the position, you should know the answers to these questions. However, even internal candidates should refresh their memory about these critical topics.

3. Practice Your Responses

One of the key benefits of practicing your interview responses is the boost in confidence it provides. As you familiarize yourself with common interview questions and practice your answers, you become more comfortable and confident in articulating your thoughts clearly and effectively. This confidence shines through during the interview, allowing you to present yourself composed and self-assuredly.

Practicing your responses helps you develop clear and concise communication skills. Rehearsing your answers can refine your thoughts, structure your responses, and eliminate unnecessary information. This ensures you deliver your key points effectively, avoiding rambling or going off-topic. Employers highly value clear and articulate communication, demonstrating your ability to convey ideas and information professionally and coherently.

4. Be Confident, Not Arrogant

Confidence is essential in making a great first impression, but it’s crucial not to be arrogant.

During the interview, discussing your accomplishments and demonstrating your capabilities is essential. However, it’s vital to strike a balance by presenting your achievements humbly and modestly. Instead of listing your accomplishments as a means of self-promotion, frame them as examples of how you contributed to previous organizations or projects. Emphasize the collaborative aspects, acknowledging the contributions of others and the support you received. This approach conveys confidence in your abilities without coming across as arrogant.

It is critical to remember that you are trying to convince the interview board that the department and the community will be improved by hiring you, not that you are a great person.

5. Use Positive Body Language

Body language is a significant component of communication. Use positive body language during your interview, such as sitting up straight, maintaining eye contact, and smiling when appropriate. Avoid negative body language, such as slouching, crossing your arms, or avoiding eye contact, as it can make you appear uninterested or untrustworthy. I was sitting on an interview panel once where a candidate repeatedly tapped the ink pen in his hand on the table to the point that it became distracting. Make sure nothing is in your hands.

6. Show Your Emotional Intelligence

As a police chief, emotional intelligence is a critical skill. Demonstrating your ability to understand and manage your emotions, as well as the feelings of others, will make you stand out as a leader. Show empathy and active listening skills during the interview, and use examples from your career where you have successfully navigated emotional situations.

7. Showcase Your Vision

A vision for the department’s future is necessary for any police chief. During the interview, showcase your overall vision but be careful about getting into too many details. As a candidate, you may or may not need more information to develop a specific vision depending on if you are an internal or external candidate. The best course of action is to communicate a general statement and the fact that the first 100 days of your tenure will be used to help identify the department’s needs and solidify the vision. Also, remain open to feedback and suggestions from the interviewers.

8. Follow Up

After the interview, send a thank-you email or note to the interviewers, thanking them for their time and reiterating your interest in the position. This gesture demonstrates your professionalism and attention to detail. You may only have the email address of the person who set up the meeting. If that is the case, send the thank you email to them.

In conclusion, becoming a police chief is a challenging but rewarding career path. Making a great first impression during the interview is crucial to securing the position. None of the suggested ways to make an excellent first impression by themself will help you get selected. Combined, though, they could be the difference maker.

Sign up below for my periodic newsletter.