Untangling the Knot: Can Electing Police Chiefs Depoliticize Policing?
Unlike sheriffs, the majority of police chiefs in the United States are appointed by City or County Managers, Mayors, Commission Chairs, or some other official. Typically, in small and large cities, the police chief reports directly to the mayor or other elected official, which can make the police chief's job difficult because of politics. In the cities in between, a professional, such as a City Manager, appoints the police chief.This gives the chief some distance from politics, at least in theory. Problem In the intricate web of law enforcement, the intersection of politics and policing is undeniable. From setting priorities to allocating resources, political considerations often permeate every facet of police work. Against this backdrop, the question arises: Can electing police chiefs take the politics out of policing? This inquiry delves into the complexities of law enforcement leadership, examining the potential merits and pitfalls of electoral processes in depoliticizing policing. Elected Police Chiefs? Up until a few years ago, I had no idea that police chiefs in some cities are elected instead of appointed by City or County Managers, Mayors, or Commission Chairs. Years ago, I ran across a news article about Chief Garrett Grogan of the Patterson, Louisiana Police…